Texas-only MVP · Free comparison math · No sign-up
HOA/MUD/PID Cost Comparison (Texas new-construction)
Texas informational estimate only; HOA, MUD, PID, property-tax, assessment, exemption, and disclosure rules vary by location and document. This is not a tax assessment, tax advice, legal opinion, district forecast, or eligibility determination. Official county, district, HOA, and transaction documents control.
Independent consumer calculator. Not affiliated with any government agency, lender, builder, MLS, appraisal district, tax authority, or other service provider unless expressly identified on the relevant placement.
A Texas new-construction monthly payment can omit HOA dues and special-district charges, and the same house can sit in a MUD, a PID, both, or neither — each billed by a different entity on a different document. This tool puts two Texas communities side by side using amounts you transcribe from official county, district, HOA, and transaction documents, annualizes each charge by its payment frequency, and reports year-1 and selected-horizon nominal totals with the modeled difference between the two. Every number is a user-entered figure from a dated source; charge labels are kept exactly as your documents name them.
Worked example
Worked example: a Fort Bend County MUD community vs a PID community over 10 years
Illustrative Community A (MUD): $95.00/month HOA dues, a $5,200.00/year charge from Fort Bend County MUD No. 169 (as named on its rate order), and $7,400.00/year property tax from the county statement. Illustrative Community B (PID): $260.00/quarter HOA dues, a $1,850.00/year assessment from Fulshear PID No. 1 (as named on its assessment roll), $8,100.00/year property tax, and a $2,500.00 one-time special assessment. Both sides use a 2% escalation scenario. Escalated amounts are a user-entered scenario, not a forecast.
Community A (MUD): year-1 charges
$13,740.00 /year · HOA $1,140.00 · district $5,200.00
Community B (PID): year-1 charges
$10,990.00 /year · HOA $1,040.00 · district $1,850.00
Over 10 years, the modeled nominal total for Community A is $150,449.17 and for Community B $122,837.45 (including its one-time special assessment) — a modeled difference of $27,611.72 (A minus B). The table shows both totals.
| Total | Community A (MUD) | Community B (PID) | Modeled difference (A − B) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year-1 annual charges | $13,740.00 | $10,990.00 | $2,750.00 |
| 10-year nominal total (incl. one-time assessments) | $150,449.17 | $122,837.45 | $27,611.72 |
Interactive
Run your own Texas comparison
Enter each community's charges from its official documents — county, source, and date are required — and leave anything undisclosed blank. Blank fields count as $0 and are listed in a visible missing-disclosures note so the comparison never hides what it does not know.
Community A
MUD / PID charges (labels exactly as named in your documents)
Community B
MUD / PID charges (labels exactly as named in your documents)
Community A: year-1 charges / 10-year total
$13,740.00 /yr · $150,449.17 over 10 years
HOA $1,140.00 · districts $5,200.00 · property tax $7,400.00 · other $0.00 · one-time $0.00
- Fort Bend County MUD No. 169 (MUD): $5,200.00/yr
Community B: year-1 charges / 10-year total
$10,990.00 /yr · $122,837.45 over 10 years
HOA $1,040.00 · districts $1,850.00 · property tax $8,100.00 · other $0.00 · one-time $2,500.00
- Fulshear PID No. 1 (PID): $1,850.00/yr
| Total | Community A | Community B | Modeled difference (A − B) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year-1 annual charges | $13,740.00 | $10,990.00 | $2,750.00 |
| 10-year nominal total (incl. one-time assessments) | $150,449.17 | $122,837.45 | $27,611.72 |
A positive modeled difference means Community A has the higher modeled charges; a negative one means Community B does. Escalated amounts are a user-entered scenario, not a forecast. Blank fields count as $0 and are listed above so you can see exactly which disclosures are missing.
The math
How the math works
Each recurring charge is annualized by its payment frequency: annual amount = entered amount × 12 (monthly), × 4 (quarterly), × 2 (semiannual), or × 1 (annual), rounded to cents per charge. The year-1 annual total is annualized HOA dues + annualized MUD/PID charges + annual property tax + other annual charges. With an escalation percentage g, the year-y amount is year-1 total × (1 + g)y−1, rounded per year; the selected-horizon nominal total is the sum of those years plus any one-time special assessment. The modeled difference is Community A minus Community B at both the year-1 and horizon totals. Escalated amounts are a user-entered scenario, not a forecast.
Fine print
Assumptions and limitations
- Texas informational estimate only; HOA, MUD, PID, property-tax, assessment, exemption, and disclosure rules vary by location and document. This is not a tax assessment, tax advice, legal opinion, district forecast, or eligibility determination. Official county, district, HOA, and transaction documents control.
- Every amount is a user-entered figure transcribed from an official county, district, HOA, or transaction document with a recorded source and date — nothing here is a verified, looked-up, or live rate.
- Charge labels are preserved exactly as your source documents name them. The tool never relabels a charge, and never calls a charge a tax when the source says otherwise.
- Escalated amounts are a user-entered scenario, not a forecast. Leaving escalation blank uses 0% — a stated default assumption, not a claim that charges stay flat.
- Totals are nominal dollars over the selected horizon; there is no discounting, no exemption math, and no tax-treatment result of any kind.
- Blank optional fields are treated as $0 and listed in the visible missing-disclosures note; an empty district list is flagged the same way. The tool never substitutes a hidden default, so a community with missing disclosures is understated by whatever those charges really are.
- Independent consumer calculator. Not affiliated with any government agency, lender, builder, MLS, appraisal district, tax authority, or other service provider unless expressly identified on the relevant placement.
Important: This independent consumer calculator provides estimates for education and comparison only. It is not a lender, mortgage broker, builder, real estate broker, appraiser, tax professional, attorney, financial adviser, or government agency, and it is not an offer, quote, approval, commitment, Loan Estimate, Closing Disclosure, appraisal, inspection, or other legal or financial document. Results are not a guarantee of savings, payment, qualification, price, availability, or outcome. Verify all figures, terms, eligibility, fees, taxes, HOA/MUD/PID charges, incentives, construction terms, and provider disclosures with the relevant provider and a qualified professional before relying on them. We do not provide legal, tax, mortgage, lending, or investment advice.
Answers
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between HOA dues, a MUD charge, and a PID assessment?
HOA dues are set by a homeowners association under its governing documents and budget. A MUD (municipal utility district) is a political subdivision whose charges usually appear on the county tax statement. A PID (public improvement district) levies assessments under a city or county service and assessment plan and assessment roll. They are billed by different entities, on different documents, sometimes on different schedules, and their legal treatment differs — which is why this tool keeps each one in its own labeled field, preserves the exact name your source document uses, and never calls a charge a tax when the source says otherwise.
Why is this tool limited to Texas?
The charge structures, document types, and terminology in this tool — MUD rate orders, PID service and assessment plans, county appraisal district statements — are specific to Texas, and the reference material is the Texas Comptroller's property-tax resources. District and disclosure rules elsewhere differ enough that a generalized version would mislead, so the tool asserts a Texas-only scope instead of quietly defaulting other states in.
How does the escalation percentage work?
The escalation percentage you enter compounds each community's year-1 annual total: the year-y amount is the year-1 total multiplied by (1 + g) raised to (y − 1), rounded to cents each year, and the horizon total is the sum of those years plus any one-time special assessment. Escalated amounts are a user-entered scenario, not a forecast. The tool never supplies its own growth number and does not know what a district, taxing unit, or association will actually charge in any future year.
What happens when I leave a field blank or enter no districts?
A blank optional field is treated as zero in the math and listed in a visible missing-disclosures note for that community. Entering no MUD/PID charges is flagged the same way, because many new-construction communities in Texas sit inside at least one district and an empty list often means the disclosure has not been located yet. The tool never fills in a hidden default, so a community with missing disclosures is understated by whatever those charges actually turn out to be.
Where do I find the official amounts?
Annual property tax and most MUD charges appear on the county tax statement or the county appraisal district's records; a MUD's adopted rate order comes from the district; a PID's assessment comes from the city or county service and assessment plan and assessment roll; HOA dues come from the association's current budget or a resale certificate. The Texas Comptroller's property-tax pages explain how these pieces fit together. Record the document name and its date in the source fields so every number in the comparison stays traceable.
References
Sources
Cited for Texas property-tax context only. Your own official county, district, HOA, and transaction documents are the controlling sources for every amount you enter.
Updated 2026-08-17.
Worksheet
Take the comparison to your document hunt
The printable Texas New-Home District Cost Pack turns this comparison into a worksheet: a source log for each county, district, HOA, and transaction document, the questions to ask the builder, title company, and district about each charge, and a page to record both communities side by side.
Sponsor placement available. Affiliate and sponsor disclosure.